phase: 15_agent_mtls
All green. Report:
**Verified / implemented (final pass of `15_agent_mtls`)**
- Wrote `data/logs/verify-15-tls-e2e.py`: a real `host_agent.py --cert-bundle` + a real dashboard process over a scratch DB (`HOST_TARGETS=loop=https://…`) — **27/27 PASS**, transcript `verify-15-tls-e2e.out`, notes `data/logs/NOTES-tls-rollout.md`.
- Read-only checks against the running dev store: 5 `certs.*` rows byte-identical across a restart; served bundle == the `meta` row (1430 B); 0 events containing `-----BEGIN`; unsigned `/certs`→`303 ?next=`, unsigned `/api/certs`→`401`, signed-in `200`; screenshots `data/logs/15-final-{certs,system}.png`.
- Docs (step 6, full review): README — added *Protecting an agent, host by host* (the rollout task-07 left out), a `tests/test_certs.py`/TLS-matrix/sandbox-installer paragraph, and fixed two stale “the one write endpoint in the app” claims (`NUT_ALLOW_ACTIONS`, Battery-test buttons). AGENTS.md — test count 1424→1427, bundle-fetch command in *Commands*, a Testing-policy bullet on structurally pinning a key-holding module, fleet transport bullet (token mode is now the compatibility path), gap 11 final state.
**Tests / lint (full suite 100% green)**
- `uv run pytest` → **1427 passed, 15 skipped**, exit 0 · `bash .agents/validate.sh` → **exit 0** (coverage **98.94%** vs 94% floor, `certs.py` 100%; ruff “All checks passed”; pyright 0 errors; `node --check` clean; hygiene clean)
- `uv run pytest -m live --live` → **11 passed / 0 failed** · `./scripts/dev-server.sh status` → all 9 sources `ok`
- `uv pip list --outdated` → empty after bumping `fastapi 0.152.0 → 0.153.0` (`uv.lock` only); full suite re-run green.
**Completion criteria**
- Fresh-DB root CA, idempotent: ✅ (tests + live store hashes) · agent TLS matrix incl. wrong-CA/certless 403/`/health` CA-only/revoked 403 + live denylist re-read: ✅
- `https` `host:`/`disks:` `ok` + revoked says “agent certificate revoked” with no dial: ✅ on loopback (real agent + real dashboard) and spy-pinned hermetically; **not** on the fleet (below)
- Signed-in `/certs` + rotate/revoke/root-rotate + byte-identical bundle download: ✅ · installer bundle/unit/`--status` over TLS: ✅ (0640, see deviation)
- `pytest`/`validate.sh`/`--outdated`: ✅ · token-mode byte-identical, engine/UPS untouched, public surface unchanged (route walk): ✅
- **Live fleet TLS (deskwork+gateway flip): NOT done** — no live changes. It needs root on hosts without the installer grant (`deskwork`), has no both-ways-working window (`http://` dashboard vs https-only agent), and would deploy the agent from this not-yet-committed tree. Exact procedure recorded in README + `data/logs/NOTES-tls-rollout.md`.
**Deviations**: bundle mode `0640 root:dashboards-agent` instead of the task file’s `0600` (the agent re-reads its own bundle for the denylist; 0600 breaks the unit — already recorded in AGENTS.md); the loopback dashboard substitutes for the fleet flip. Incidental: a stray `pkill` of mine killed the dev server mid-pass; restarted and verified healthy.
**Next pending phase**: `.agents/phases/todo/16_agent_smart_pass_budget` (then `17_installer_device_filter`).
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,37 @@
|
||||
# Task 02 — The agent serves a protected TLS web server from one installed bundle
|
||||
|
||||
**Phase:** `15_agent_mtls` · **Source:** `TODO.md:3` — "I want all exporters to be protected web servers. The collector should generate and manage a root certificate that needs to be installed with each exporter. Use the certs as auth to each exporter."
|
||||
|
||||
## Objective
|
||||
|
||||
`host_agent.py` gains a TLS mode that makes the web server protected by certificate: one installed bundle holds the server cert + key, the root CA, a bundle revision, and a revocation list; the agent requires a client cert signed by the root on every path except `/health` (mirroring the token-mode `/health` exemption, so an installer probe can reach `/health` with the CA only), and it reports the bundle revision it loaded so the dashboard can tell a stale bundle from a fresh one. The token mode is byte-identical to today.
|
||||
|
||||
## Work
|
||||
|
||||
1. `agent/host_agent.py` — stdlib only (an `ssl` import; no new third-party dependency):
|
||||
- a new flag `--cert-bundle <file>` (env `AGENT_CERT_BUNDLE`): one PEM text containing the server cert, the server key, the root CA cert, a `# BUNDLE-REV <n>` line, and `# REVOKED <serial>` lines. `resolve_bundle(path) -> (context, bundle_rev, revoked: frozenset[str], error)` is a pure function (the `resolve_token` idiom): parse the PEM blocks by text, extract the three blocks, write them to a temp dir for `load_cert_chain` (into `/run/dashboards-agent` when present and writable — the unit's `RuntimeDirectory`, task 06 — else `tempfile.mkdtemp`), and build the context.
|
||||
- The TLS context: `ssl.SSLContext(ssl.PROTOCOL_TLS_SERVER)`, `load_cert_chain`, `load_verify_locations(ca)`, `verify_mode = ssl.CERT_OPTIONAL` — the handshake is optional and the **handler** enforces it: on every path except `/health`, `self.connection.getpeercert()` must carry a verified certificate (subject present), else `403 {"ok": false, "detail": "client certificate required"}`; that cert's serial must not be in the bundle's `# REVOKED` set, else `403 {"ok": false, "detail": "client certificate revoked"}`. The denylist file is re-read on mtime change per request (a small file; a redeployed bundle takes effect without a restart — the reason the `# REVOKED` lines live in the bundle at all).
|
||||
- The startup gate: off-loopback with neither a token nor a bundle → the existing exit-2 refusal (its message now names the bundle too); a bundle present → the off-loopback bind is allowed (the client cert is the protection); a token plus a bundle → the token check is skipped on the TLS path (the handshake is the auth).
|
||||
- The snapshot payload gains two **additive** top-level fields in TLS mode: `tls: true` and `bundle_rev: <n>` (absent in token mode — an additive field never changes an existing shape); the `serve()` start line says `tls (client cert required, rev <n>)`.
|
||||
- `AGENT_VERSION` 1.0.0 → 1.1.0; the docstring's deployment paragraph gains one line for the TLS mode (no flavour text — the AGENTS.md audit rule).
|
||||
- ASSUMPTION: `CERT_OPTIONAL` + the per-path check (not `CERT_REQUIRED`) is what keeps `/health` probeable with the CA only — the installer's `--status` and the systemd probe (task 06) cannot present a client cert the installer does not hold, and a probe that cannot health-check is a dead install.
|
||||
- ASSUMPTION: the agent never generates or renews certificates (stdlib cannot mint x509); the bundle is the artifact the dashboard signs and the installer places.
|
||||
2. `tests/test_agent.py` — the existing in-process harness (`serve()` in a thread on `127.0.0.1`, `urllib`/`ssl` clients), with a test CA + leafs generated by `src/dashboards/certs.py` over a dict store (no second generator):
|
||||
- a client with a matching client cert → `/snapshot` 200 with `tls: true` and `bundle_rev` equal to the bundle's;
|
||||
- a client with no cert → the handshake fails or a 403 on a non-`/health` path; `/health` still 200 with a CA-only context (the probe path);
|
||||
- a client signed by a *different* CA → refused;
|
||||
- a client whose serial is in the bundle's `# REVOKED` list → 403 "revoked"; rewrite the bundle file without the line (mtime change) → the same client is accepted on the next request (the denylist re-read);
|
||||
- a token-mode agent (no bundle): the existing tests unchanged and green (byte-identical behaviour — no `tls`/`bundle_rev` fields);
|
||||
- `resolve_bundle` error paths: a missing file, an empty file, a bundle missing the key block, a bundle missing the `# BUNDLE-REV` line (an error — a revless bundle is not one this app signed; ASSUMPTION: the `# BUNDLE-REV` line is mandatory).
|
||||
3. `deploy/` is untouched here (task 06); the non-systemd fallback (`tempfile.mkdtemp`) keeps dev and tests working.
|
||||
|
||||
## Testing & Quality
|
||||
|
||||
- the `tests/test_agent.py` matrix above; the existing token-mode tests stay green unchanged.
|
||||
- Coverage: **>90%** on this task's new/modified code.
|
||||
|
||||
## Completion Criteria
|
||||
|
||||
- [ ] a TLS-mode agent on a loopback port answers the full handshake matrix (tests) and reports `bundle_rev`
|
||||
- [ ] a token-mode agent is byte-identical to today (existing tests green, no new fields present)
|
||||
- [ ] `uv run pytest` green; `uv run ruff check src tests agent` + `uv run pyright` clean
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user